tomgpalmer.com  
Tom G. Palmer

January 14, 2007

Thank God the Congress is a Deliberative Body

Klingons%20and%20Vulkans%20in%20the%20White%20House.jpg “But unlike the real Klingons of Star Trek….”

Representative David Wu of Oregon has raised the level of debate in Congress.

Hat Tip: Reason’s Hit & Run.

Posted by Tom Palmer at January 14, 2007 7:37 AM | TrackBack
Comments

"And like the real idiots of Congress..." What a goof!

Posted by: Andy H. at January 14, 2007 11:20 AM

Honestly though, this is a congressional speech that would actually grab the attention of an American audience that could give a rats ass about what happens in our gov't. Or understands half of what is being discussed. People with a IQ of 130 and above aren't the only ones who vote.

Posted by: at January 14, 2007 11:50 AM

Actually, to the extent that he was making arguments that haven't been made often in the past 6 years, he was raising the level of debate.

Posted by: Damon Chetson at January 14, 2007 2:20 PM

Good points, all. I just find it a bit ... well, odd that in a speech before Congress such childish points would be made.

I also don't think that he really made anything clearer with references to "Vulcans" and "Klingons." Had they actually clarified anything, the references would have been welcome.

Posted by: Tom G. Palmer at January 14, 2007 2:24 PM

Damon is right; this is a great improvement over "support our troops, stay the course, everyone not with us is against us and pro-terrorist."

And Tom, I think the Star Trek metaphors *are* fairly clear. And there are likely more people who are regular consumers of Star Trek than, say, Foreign Affairs (even just among those with IQs over 130 -- take that, anon.)

But best of all in this clip is the new term "faux Klingon." This gem is a fine replacement for the tired old "chickenhawk." May this become the standard term for the Bush admin. foreign policy crew.

Posted by: Charles N. Steele at January 15, 2007 11:53 AM

Well, points well taken. I was just struck by the term "the *real* Klingons of Star Trek." But it's true that it's more intelligent than calling critics of the president "traitors," which is how low the pro-war right has fallen.

As to "faux Klingons," they sound to me like the kind of problem that sweater wearers might face.

Posted by: Tom G. Palmer at January 15, 2007 12:28 PM

Why must fellow Star Trek fans shame me at every turn? Can I have no dignity?

Posted by: Aaron G. at January 19, 2007 3:11 AM